Now that Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi is being
officially crowned as BJP’s PM candidate, it is now time for the Indian voters
to take a major decision. Every day I come across innumerable people who
support Modi for his so-called development in Gujarat and trust me when I give
them rationale reasons which clears the myth, I do see a shift of ideologies.
But as the great saying says, you can never defeat an ignorant person in an argument
and so some people will never buy your arguments, howsoever factual it might
be. What he did in 2002 is something which is for me unquestionably a brutal
and heinous crime, but for the time being even if we keep the communal card
aside, there are plentiful to talk about. So I decided to make a report card of
Modi as the Chief Minister of Gujarat over the years and burst the myth for
everyone.
First, about the
rate of economic growth, during 1995-2000 and 2001-10, Gujarat increased its
annual rate of growth from 8.01% to 8.68%. But so is the case with other major
states such as Andhra Pradesh, Haryana, Maharashtra, Punjab, Tamil Nadu and
Uttar Pradesh. In fact, Gujarat was ranked second after Rajasthan (8.34%) in
the first period and third after Uttarakhand (11.81%) and Haryana (8.95%) in
the second period. What is remarkable, Bihar and Orissa, the two most backward
and poverty-stricken states have also shown growth pick up from 4.70% and 4.42%
in the first period to 8.02% and 8.13% in the second period. Even smaller
states like Sikkim and Arunachal Pradesh have registered growth of 11.01% and
8.96%, respectively.
During 2001-04, the rate of industrial growth for
Gujarat was 3.95%, and during 2005-09, it was 12.65%. In isolation, this
appears to be a phenomenal jump, but not so when compared to some other states.
During these sub-periods, industrial growth for Orissa was 6.4% and 17.53%; for
Chhattisgarh 8.10% and 13.3%; and for Uttarakhand 18.84% and 11.63%. Thus, the
hitherto industrially backward states have far surpassed Gujarat. In FDI, too,
Gujarat has not been a leading state. During 2006-10, Gujarat signed MoUs worth
Rs 5.35 lakh crore with potential of 6.47 lakh jobs. But Maharashtra and Tamil
Nadu with Rs 4.20 lakh crore and Rs 1.63 lakh crore worth MoUs, expect about
8.63 lakh and 13.09 lakh jobs. To top it all, Chhattisgarh and Orissa have
signed MoUs worth Rs 3.61 lakh crore and Rs 2.99 lakh crore more than Gujarat
without much fanfare and Modi’s much-hyped industrial summits.
In the area of credit-deposit ratio, Gujarat is far
behind other major states. In 2010, Gujarat’s share in total deposits of the
scheduled commercial banks was 4.70%, as against 5.42%, 6.20%, 6.34% and 26.60%
for Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka and Maharashtra, respectively. The share
of Gujarat in total credit disbursed by these commercial banks was 4.22%; while
the same for Maharashtra, Karnataka and Tami Nadu was 29.75%, 6.71% and 9.61%
respectively. The amount of per capita deposit and per capita credit for Gujarat
was Rs 37,174 and Rs 24,268; while for Tamil Nadu, it was Rs 42,580 and Rs
47,964; Karnataka Rs 49,598 and Rs 38,154; and Maharashtra Rs 1,10,183 and Rs
89,575. Even Kerala did better than Gujarat with Rs 43,890 and Rs 27,912. In
terms of per capita income (PCI), in 2011, Gujarat ranked sixth among major
states with PCI of Rs 63,996, after Haryana (Rs 92,327), Maharashtra, (Rs
83,471), Punjab (Rs 67,473), Tamil Nadu (Rs 72,993) and Uttarakhand (Rs
68,292).
What
about inclusive growth in Gujarat? Though Gujarat, with 31.8% people below the
poverty line did better than Maharashtra and Karnataka, it still lagged behind
Kerala, Punjab, Himachal Pradesh and Haryana, where poverty levels were 19.7%,
20.9%, 22.9% and 24.1%, respectively. On three important social indicators, viz
life expectancy at birth (LEB), mean years of schooling (MYS) and school life
expectancy (SLE), Gujarat is far behind some other states. In Gujarat, the LEB
during 2002-06 was 64.1 years and it ranked ninth among major Indian states. In
the areas of MYS and SLE, during 2004-05, it ranked seventh and ninth,
respectively. Kerala ranked first in all three indicators. Even Maharashtra,
Himachal Pradesh, Punjab, Haryana, Tamil Nadu and Karnataka performed much better
than Gujarat.
With
respect to Human Development Index (HDI), Gujarat’s story is devastating. The
HDI for Gujarat, in 2008, was 0.527 and it ranked 10th among major states.
Kerala stood first (HDI: 0.790), Himachal Pradesh scored 0.652, Punjab 0.605, Maharashtra
0.572 and Haryana 0.552. With respect to three HDI components – income, health
and education – Gujarat does not present a shining story. In this respect,
states like Kerala took the lead in every sector, while Punjab, Himachal
Pradesh, Haryana, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu and West Bengal did better than
Gujarat. It is found that inequality with respect to income, education and
health is higher in Gujarat than some of the major states.
Paradoxically, employment has not kept pace with the
spurt in economic growth. NSSO data show that growth in employment has dropped
to almost zero in the past 12 years. Rural Gujarat has been particularly hit
despite the fact that there has been an increase in growth in the rural sector.
The average wages (for jobs other than those under the Mahatma Gandhi National
Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme) are also very poor, putting Gujarat at a low
14th rank among the States. The disparity in wages speaks of
exploitation and an increasing use of contract workers. According to NSSO 2011
figures, the average daily wage a labourer in the informal sector in urban
areas can expect in Gujarat is Rs.106 against Rs.218 in Kerala (which ranks
first). In rural areas, Punjab ranks the highest at Rs.152 a day while Gujarat
stands 12th at Rs.83. About 98 per cent of the women workers and about 89 per
cent of the male workers in the State are engaged in informal work (against the
corresponding national figures of 96 per cent and 90 per cent).
According
to statistics from a report of the Ministry of Statistics and Programme
Implementation, “Children in India, 2012—A Statistical Appraisal”, between 40
and 50 per cent of children in Gujarat are underweight, which bursts one more
myth in Gujarat’s story of growth. Other States in this low weight category are
Meghalaya, Chhattisgarh, Uttar Pradesh and Odisha. Human Development Report
2011 said around half of Gujarat’s children were malnourished. Infant
mortality, one of the basic indicators of the success of a government, is high
in Gujarat, which ranks 11th countrywide in the rate of decline of infant
mortality. According to “Children in India, 2012”, the infant mortality rate in
Gujarat was still high, with 44 fatalities of infants per 1,000 live births.
And with fewer health care facilities in rural areas, it is no surprise that
the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, both of whom are kept at the
bottom of the social ladder, have a higher mortality rate.
In its 2012
State-wise report, the United Nation’s Children’s Fund (UNICEF) said, “Almost
every second child in Gujarat under the age of five years is undernourished and
three out of four are anaemic. Infant and maternal mortality rates have reduced
very slowly in the last decade…. One mother in three in Gujarat struggles with
acute under-nutrition….” The issue of children’s health is further compounded
by the continuance of child marriage. Gujarat ranks fourth in reported cases of
child marriage. Shockingly, in
terms of hunger – as revealed by the ‘State Hunger Index 2008’ – Gujarat ranked
13th among 17 big states and worse than Orissa. In Gujarat, the percentage of
women suffering from anaemia has risen from 46.3% in 1999 to 55.5% in 2004, and
amongst children from 74.5% to 80.1%. The conditions of dalits and women have
deteriorated during the last decade; while those of Muslims and tribals are
still worse.
Education also seems to be low on
priority when it comes to government spending. The Bharatiya Janata Party’s
(BJP) election manifesto claims to have achieved 100 per cent enrolment in
primary schools and reduced the overall dropout rate by 2 per cent. United
Nations Development Programme (UNDP) statistics show that Gujarat ranks 18th
when it comes to success in keeping children in schools. The school life
expectancy of children in Kerala (which ranks first) is 11.33 years, while that
of children in Gujarat is 8.79 years. The State also ranks seventh among 15
major States in terms of literacy rates.
According to
Census 2011, 43 per cent of the rural households in Gujarat get water supply on
their premises and 16.7 per cent get treated water from a common tap. In urban
households, the corresponding percentages are 84 per cent and 69 per cent. The
data show that 67 per cent of rural households in the State have no access to
toilets and members of more than 65 per cent of the households defecate in the
open, very often polluting common water sources. Waste collection and disposal
are matters practically unheard of. The
larger issue of the environment is also severely neglected.
Despite the Modi government’s pride in the economic
boom brought on by the industrial clusters of south Gujarat, these are actually
environmentally dead zones. According to statistics from the Central Pollution
Control Board, Ankleshwar and Vapi in Gujarat top the list of 88 severely
polluted industrial areas in India. Ankleshwar has a CEPI rating of 88.50 while
Vapi’s is 88.09. Of the 88 areas, eight are in Gujarat. Even Dhanbad in
Jharkhand, with its intensive coal mining and a longer history of pollution
than the Gujarat centres, ranks only 13th on the list.
These were just few facts that I could highlight for
you while there are innumerable more things to point out to show the mirage of
development that Modi claims of. Certainly no government is perfect and there
lies fault in every administration, but the problem lies with the fact that no
one else boasts about it so much as Narendra Modi does and now that other than
Hindutva, development is also his calling card, we certainly need to introspect
about it. In no way is he a crusader of development and not to mention not at
all an inclusive leader. I would like to conclude this report card with the
international media giant BBC’s headline while announcing Modi’s anointment as
BJP’s PM candidate which clears Modi’s international stature. It said ‘Controversial
Hindu Nationalist Politician to lead Opposition in Indian Vote’. Do I need to
say anything more? It’s time for you to think about it and take a call.
For all sorts of bouquets and brickbats feel free to
leave a comment below or mail at author.vish94@gmail.com
When can we expect report card of UPA or MMS or sonia or rahul gandhi?
ReplyDeleteEagerly waiting for that.
When you say Gujrats progress is less..
ReplyDeleteMy friend, the progress percentage of US compared to India will be less.
Because US is already a developed country.
Same with Gujrat. It is far ahead of other states.
Now, coming to other front.
This is an article from Times Of India (by World bank), which says that the roads of Gujrat are close to International standards.
This is what the Gujrati tax payer is getting.
http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2011-08-11/ahmedabad/29875862_1_km-of-state-highways-main-roads-annual-plan
In Mumbai, where we pay a lot of tax. But show me a single road which is nice :(
There is a lot more but for now this much.
By the way, I hope your figures are correct :)
All my facts are backed by sources. You can cross check them. And since you talked about roads which is a TOI article which again is not at all credible. I've a fresh info for you. You talked about roads right? See what gujarat taxpayers are getting in return.
Deletehttp://m.indianexpress.com/news/gujarat-hc-serves-notice-to-state-on-poor-condition-of-roads/1168678/
Not only this, even healthcare is pathetic. One more.
http://www.indianexpress.com/news/swine-flu-in-gujarat-hc-seeks-detailed-report-from-state-govt/1091786/
And I hope to counter this you won't say that the Gujarat High Court is not credible enough. Think about what you're supoorting.
To Author.. Can u tell me if Rajasthan, Haryana etc are not part of India? If yes, why are you soo hell bent on comparing them to Gujarat and trying to prove that Guj did not grow? Let's assume that your numbers are correct (i didnt not see any proof though), still Gujarat has done well (I can show you millions such links).
DeleteIf there is someone else from other states who think he is good enough to become PM, ask him to come forward.
As of now, there is only one man credible enough to stand there. Ask congress why don't they name the PM candidate?
Why should us voters bring to power a party who then hands us a mute dummy PM? We need to know who that person is and if he is better than Modi, we will vote.
Can you Answer this?
WHY HAVE U NOT REPLIED TO WHAT ASHISHKR HAS ASKED U, THAT MEANS U R A PAID AGENT OF CONGRESS
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteOh well yes it is very much a part of India and that is the very same reason why we're comparing them. And it is not me but your dearest Mr. Modi who keeps comparing Gujarat with other states. And as far as other CMs are concerned, if they wish to compete they will. But if they want to stay in their respective states and improve them, why not? If Mr. Modi is so concerned with Gujarat and going through a ride, let him stay there and improve the conditions first. And please just because I don't agree with him, doesn't make me a paid congress agent. Neither am I scared of anyone.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteSurprising that some people are so content with dummy PM and his foreign origin bosses that they have lost their self respect and country's pride. At least I am sure of three things about Mr. Modi:(1) He is unmarried and has no sibilings and Damads to pamper at the cost of the country (2) He is purely Indian so we will make him accountable for any future missdeeds and he may not run away to some foreign home in case of any crisis (3) He does not talk
Deleteabout pampering any religious group and create animosity among them. In fact talking of favours does much more damage than actually giving it. Cong. has been talking only about reservations and special benefits for the last 60 years without providing any visible improvements to the plight of those poor and disadvantaged groups. Those of these groups who have come up in life are only through their merit and not through reservations. Please remember that Dr. Ambedekar is a product of time when there was no reservation. Please dont start quoting statistical data. I know how they are generated and made to suit the narrow vested interests.
so you mean to say, that the scams done by CONGRESS & Sonia Gandhi, which are counted in lakhs of crores are okay. No need to worry?
ReplyDeletethey are not taking China and Pakistan seriously. Our soldiers are be-headed. That is also fine?
Assume, you father was in the army and was be-headed?
Don't you think some serious action was needed for that?
Scams certainly shouldn't be supported. But by that logic the CAG in its latest report pointed out that there are as much as Rs. 60,000 crores worth scams in Gujarat. And Mr. Modi is even not letting a Lokyakuta take over. Why? What is he scared of?
DeleteAnd as far as our borders are concerned, diplomacy is the only way out. For the BJP and NaMo serious action means a war wherein thousands of more soldiers would be killed, wives would be widowed, kids orphaned. Do you want that to happen?
Its very easy to stand on a pedestral and point out at others. But when it comes to such serious issues, there is a lot that needs to be introspected. Remember, with power comes great responsibility.
Hi Bishal, I have studied some of the economic parameters of Gujarat and compared with other states. Have a look at the below link n leave ur comment
Deletehttp://pradeephegde127.blogspot.co.uk/2013/09/rebuttal-to-modis-gujarat-model-much.html
In my opinion you are not consistent with state and period selection for the comparison study.
Hi Pradeep, I really appreciate your hard work. I'll go through your work and make sure that I'm more consistent from next time.
DeleteI have just checked some of your data like growth rate, per capita income, HDI index, which are factually wrong. Please provide me your data source.
DeleteAll my data are backed by their respective source and year to year analysis clearly. Read the blog carefully and you shall get it.
DeleteU haven't given source for growth rate, per capita income and HDI index. I have latest from planning commission web site and 2011 HDI index report. But ur data doesn't match
DeleteNicely done. Sharing :)
ReplyDeleteThanks Nerissa!! :)
DeleteSo you chose to respond selectively... Why am I not surprised :)
DeleteA tight slap for modi supporters
ReplyDeleteyeah.
DeleteBishal paul, lets take whatever u said is truth. y can't u write progress report of UPA, MMS, sonia and of course our great secular leader Budhu. Modi is really making money for himself (as u mentioned him as corrupted). if yes how much money did he made. if really 60,000 crores worth of scams happened in Gujarat, i don't think so media is so silent about that issue.
ReplyDeletediplomacy is the only way out? every day our soldiers sacrificing their lives at border. we no need go for war. but we must strengthen borders. we must give moral strength to our soldiers.
i have Gujarati friends in my lab, they are very happy in Gujarat with all basic facilities like 24 hours power, good drinking water and better transportation facilities.
let me tell u one more thing i am from Andhara, i better know how my state is (ruling by congress)
Bishal is clearly giving one-sided report. He not-praising Modi is like Sonia praising Rahul for his achievements...obviously making fool of himself
Deletelets compare the reports, progress and scams of UPA, congress, Modi for last 10 years....shall we?...and we might get the picture who is better. It's very clear that you don't support Modi...But I think India will progress more when Modi is in power, compared to Congress.
ReplyDeleteselective replying will nt help ur cause
ReplyDeletemost of the facts written here are already out in the public domain and bishal check ur maths u seem to be weak in maths - growth rate calculated on lower base will always be more than growth rate calculated on higher growth - nahi samajh me aya ask ur friends
ReplyDeleteAwesome dude..He might be asking Doggy what to reply next..
DeletePAID AGENT OF CONGRESS ......... GOOD WORK DONE ..........MAY BE TRYING TO GET SEAT IN RAJYA SABHA HAHAHAHHAHA
ReplyDeleteOh God. This is becoming increasingly funny. I've no interest in getting a seat in Rajya Sabha.
DeleteOhh now i see where this is coming from. The author is a desperate wannabe filmmaker. So what do u do when u don't get anywhere with your carrer or professional life????? U make gas talks, bogus stories, defame and demean people.
ReplyDeleteMy dear Manish. I'm a published author of a bestselling author. I might be a budding filmmaker but certianly not a 'wannabe' one. Dfaming others to gain attention is Modi/BJP/Sangh parivar culture not mine. If facts backed by credible sources are bogus, then let it be.
DeleteGood Reply to Manish Kumar,
DeleteSo Mr.Bishal Paul hope u would have sources against or in Favor of Vadra's Land Deal scam, Sources based info on
2G,CWG,Adarash,RailScam,Coalgate,Bofors,Helicopter n Many More Scam of Nehru Dynasty, so do share it with Us.
On Source Basis i read that sardar vallabhbhai patel was choice for 1st PM, How,Why n in what circumstances Nehru became 1st PM of India?
NAMO would be blamed for 2002 by Congress when Majority of Guj Muslims r in Support with him, y, Wt is Congress interest in that? n if NAMO is Accuse of 2002, Who is Responsible for Partition of India? for 1984 Sikh Riots? for Assam Riots?
When our PM was honor'd by Washington Post article with "underachiever",Prime Minister's Office told to media that has sought an apology from the paper and said that its demand was accepted but the Washington Post, for which Simon Denyer, the bureau chief replied that no apology was offered, so what respect our PM gain'd?
When India got Independence 1RS=1$ n today it had went upto 62+RS, y?
We don't want war with our Neighbor countries, but should we not response back to then, if u feel diplomacy is the only way out, then y 1965,1971 took place Under Congress,?
Hope U would reply me Sir, n its time to wake up ur soul
Good work and it is even verymuch important to spread awareness. because just his nomination news has created so many abusers and violent ppl. If he becomes PM( chances of which are very very low) then no one can save this country from destruction and divisive power that we had seen during partition. Once again Good job and amazing way of writing.
ReplyDeleteThank you so much James. Guess you can't impress everybody and so I hope they'll some day realize what the truth is.
DeleteNot done Bishal... We know u aren't a Modi supporter. But at least don't be oblivious of the corruption scams and wrong deeds of the UPA govt. I don't see any report from you on them.. For you the scams happening is nothing. The threat to our national security is nothing. You are so concerned about the economy of gujrat. The economy of India is at one of its worst positions. The value of rupee has been depreciating at an alarming rate. Development in fields of education, infrastructure, agriculture, etc are stagnated. Yet I don't see a single article of yours on these issues. You, being a student, should be disappointed for the abysmal performance of Indian universities at the global level, all because of the wrong policies of the state towards edu. Yet all we see is you giving a report card of "Modi's Development". WAKE UP BISHAL! There's a lot happening outside gujrat and modi..
ReplyDeleteWho said I'm oblivious of other things? But why there is so much panic when I expose the problems of Gujarat and faultlines in Gujarat? That is because Modi supporters know it that the moment Indian voters get aware of the truth, they'll be exposed. So while its my wish what I would like to report on, people should counter facts that I put forward every time i post something. Counter them with facts and I shall do what I need to.
DeleteMay be whatever you wrote is true and based on facts, but this still does not change the fact that there were numerous scams under congress rule and the development of the country has a whole is tumbling down. The prices of vegetables and other necessary commodities have gone way way up and we are stuck with a dumb PM who cannot speak without "madamji's" permission.
DeleteI would definitely want to know how Modi would perform if given a chance, because we have been giving Congress lots of chances in the last 65+ years.
So Mr Bishal do you still think if congress will be there coming more 5 years .Then india will attain a growth. I hope you will agree with that . Reports and Final countdown that doesn't matter anymore. One thing which matter is .If you are really patriotic and you love your country .Support modi to come to power. Otherwise if congress is still there for coming 5 years .I dont know about you .But definitely people like us (averaged salary) person's will be on road begging .You will find indians on bangladesh and country like somalia for jobs.Still its your choice and india is democratic.Is you wanna see that part of india .Go ahead Vote for congress.You dont know the power of words . Your suggestion may change few people minds.And bhagwan na kare aisa hoo gaya ki.Congress fir se aayegi .India will be like afghanistan . Save your country vote for BJP(Narendar Modi).It's just an opinion like you made nothing else.
ReplyDeletehahaha..another looser out there..keep writing..U think gujratis are fool to elect him 3 times again and again? Or your this blog will reduce his vote shares? what do u want to prove? when people ask you report card of pappu khan and MMS, u have no answers. Anyways, keep writing, good luck. You are next dogvijay singh in making
ReplyDeleteMr Paul,
ReplyDeleteNot that I want to comment on your article because I am Modi fan or critic, but I ask you one simple thing. What do you think about your tunch maal Digvijaya singh who has tweeted your link? Did he searched that over internet? Or did you mail him? Whatever be the case, You know, all these facts,numbers and all the things you have mentioned "with substantial proofs", hold no meaning to the people who hear daily debates. they have been cited numerous times, in fact more than our ears can tolerate. Anyways, Lets consider all you said is true, Do you feel that the hardline media, which has so many critics (which is good for anybody to know their shortcomings), will not plan any prime debate based on these facts? Modi speaks a lot..trust me a lot.. He says thousand words.. may be some figures go overboard (Like the china one you mentioned).. Even the most skilled bowler sometimes throw wide and no balls.. His job is to speak, he is doing that, there are no balls sometimes. But I must say instead of writing or searching a lot, (because there is lots of garbage against Modi).. why you forget there are 28 more states in India which need some attention, media is not giving, even an intelligent person like you is ignoring you because Modi brings some traffic on the website.. Well you wrote such a wonderful novel called footprints of life..have pictures with celebrities.. started your page in december 2012.. still 519 likes only? Is there something missing? I saw many of your blogs were against Modi, You think we Indians are assholes? There are many budding stupid writers like you, and trust nobody gives a shit about you.. Your credibility died when Mr DIGVIJAYA SINGH tweeted your link.. I can follow Manmohan.. Rahul even Sonia.. but Diggi.. ahh common man.. I am sorry but you stink.. I am sorry for hard language, but I believe you deserved little more..If want any one on one discussion.. reply me, lets have a fair debate, and leave footprints of truth!
1. Would you please share the data sources of the claims made in your article above, each claim please.
ReplyDelete2. Most of your data points point out to years 2004/2005. Have you chosen these years according to your suitability or convenience? If not, please update to latest available indicators.
3. Interestingly, most of your claims compare apples to oranges viz: BJP claims about 100% primary school enrollment and you counter it with some UNDP report on continuity of eductaion.
4. 3 basic needs of a citizen would be security, infrastructure and earning opportunity within the given social structure he/she resides. I need not quote any UN report for these indicators... You will need to live in Gujarat to answer that.
5. I will be really grateful, if you can show your criticism talent for preparing a similar report card of UPA's decade of decay. You seem to be much better in analyzing state of economy when compared to biggest Corporate leaders and talents like Reliance, Tatas, GM, Maruti, etc etc.. They surely will learn a couple of lessons from you :)
AND
Finally, How do you know Mr. Digvijay Singh? curious since someone from congress party is sharing a blogspot (UK?) link for propaganda. Did you meet him before writing this or was this article a result of brief given by Mr. Singh or his stooges in Congress?
I'm just a curious Indian citizen and voter who will decide objectively on the basis of performance measured through experience of government.
Thank You!
Well, you compared Gujarat on various parameters against different states and it looked like on most of the parameters Gujarat was right up there, in the top 5, while most of the states you compared it against kept rotating. Isn't that in a way a compliment to Narendra Modi?
ReplyDeleteI don't know, just saying I heard his speech at Rewari and it appeared that he wasn't talking about starting a war with Pakistan. He certainly spoke of a better and a smarter diplomacy in how we deal with Pakistan and that did sound rationale.
Anyhow, I am kind of surprised to see the two lines of thought in India. One that is pro Modi and one that is against Modi. For the folks that are against Modi, I would love to hear what leader they support and the thought process behind it. However that is absolutely missing. What are your thoughts?
Gandhiji had said: "Knowledge without devotion is like a misfire." Cry for NaMo is that misfire of too much knowledge minus spirituality circulating around.
ReplyDeleteI am from Gujarat .. and i feel it has developed a lot during the tenure of Modi. Are PPL of Gujarat fools in voting for Modi everytime. What do you have to say on that?
ReplyDeletei agree to what you say. Why expose only the state of gujarat?? Why different yardstick to measure the growth of gujarat? If you really want to do so, why not do the same with states like maharastra(your home state) west bengal, U.P, Bihar or even J.K?? Just because you wan to prove your point dosent mean people are dumb to listen to your crap. If you are so concerned about India, do make a report on UPA last 10 years rule and compare with gujarat.
ReplyDeletehahahaha... good one... the author will not reply now :)
DeleteDear All,
ReplyDeletePlease ignore this writer. I went through his blog and found most of his blogs are anti BJP/RSs. A CONGRESS CHAMCHA IN THE MAKING. No credibility what so ever. Guess the congress is paying this guy well enough to write this shit articles. Good luck to you Mr congress chamcha.
Dear All,
ReplyDeleteHe is definitely a paid congress worker. we all know what congress has done in the last 50+ years, just did vote bank politics and worked hard to maintain poverty so that they can copy the speech of Ms.indira gandhi
I have seen exactly this same article on many other blogs.
ReplyDeleteYou have lost credibility.
Its a paid CONGRESS article. Sad :(
After what we have seen in last 10 years, please give Modi one chance.
ReplyDeleteWe need a change.
Wikileaks said Modi is Incorruptible. What else could you ask for.
http://www.indianexpress.com/news/incorruptible-in-wikileaks-narendra-modi-smiles/766153/
you are showing official statistics, but actually Industrial investment increased in Gujrat. Power sector is growing, Road development, Construction and other basic facilities increased. I think that Gujrat Model is best
ReplyDeleteStock suggestions, Call Put Option
Well written man. congrats for such a hard work and dedication towards showing your loyalty towards Congress. Its very common in India if you want some cheap popularity or want to show your writing skill then write about mr. Modi as some media agent or some congressi leader will definitely pick your content without checking its authenticity. Digvijay Singh twitted the link to your article and people started reading it. I don't know where to start commenting about your Article as neither I am a good writer like you neither I am having data to contradict you. But somehow taking courage to challenge your article on some reputed media house report which is definately more authentic than you
ReplyDeletehttp://ibnlive.in.com/news/gujarat-24hour-power-supply-in-over-18000-villages/250309-3.html
Now come to Road Infrastructure in Gujarat
This Article is based on world bank report much before modi elevation in Party
http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2010-08-24/ahmedabad/28273169_1_road-network-highway-sector-km
Now read about employment
http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/industry-and-economy/haryana-gujarat-top-in-generating-industry-jobs-assocham/article4142999.ece
In the sameway I can show you 100 such articles my national and internationa media about growth story og Gujrat. And also governemet agencies data about Gujrat but I dont have time for that.
Now talking without proof and data
Comparision of Gujrat with Haryana and Punjab
India is a country of diversity. Punjab and Haryana have advantage of Agriculture based economy their land are much more fertile than Gujrat. In term of agricultural produce Punjab and Haryana have climatic advantage over Gujrat. Most of the farmers and rural population in Punjab and Haryana are dependent on agriculture and due to higher productivity their per capita income could be higher than Rural people of Gujrat. So comparing Gujrat with Haryana and Punjab is baseless. Those who compare are seculaar illiterate people.
Comparison of Chhatisgarh and Uttrakhand with Gujrat.
IT will be very unfair to compare to compare these two new states with Gujrat. These are very new state and they are still very poor. Though both the states were BJP ruled bt Now Uttrakhand is with congress. When you start constructing your new house there is definitely more chances of growth but as soon as you construct a house your growth level come to stagnation. You might go for a second house when you have surplus money that a very rare case in India. same way Uttrakhand and Chhatishgarh are creating their first home so growth is high. You can see India, China and America for example. India is around 5%, China is at 9%+ and America is slight above of 2% but it doesnt means american have poor life than China and India. America is developed country while India & China is developing. China is devoloping over 8-9% as they donot have corruption, Non performing government issues but we have so many inter issues that why our GDP is hitting low every quarter.
Comparing Orisa with Gujrat is justified. Orisa is developing fastter way and I am giving credit to Sri Navin patnayak ji and his party.
Comparing Gujrat with other states like Maharastra, Kerla or Andra is some how justifiable but see it from different agle. See last 10 year report card of Mr. Modi not 60 year report card in which 40 year has been ruled by Congress.
No more time to write otherwise would love to answer your every point in article. My advice to you. If you writing for Congress then its well justified article but if you writing as journalist or want to be a journalist then change your mindset before writing.
Disclaimer- I am supporter of development of India . People have all the write to say I am BJP paid or NaMo supporter. I will not mind
Modi is a great leader and India needs him. And he will come to power as the PM wheather idiots like you like it or not.
ReplyDeleteOK first I want to say that the facts are picked up from internet completely so no need to crosscheck on internet but I don't think internet tells you everything true but a person who lives in gujrat will tell you the truth and by the way if congress showing up so many scams in its ruling years can claim of doing Bharat Nirman why can't we believe that gujrat has developed in modi sarkar?
ReplyDeleteAll Modi's jackasses started barking as they have seen this article, it show how protective they are!! he does not stand any chance to become PM at least till 2074 & he does not deserve to be.
ReplyDelete